|
RESURGENS
***August 25, 2026*** "I still don't see why we have to get dressed up to drink tea," Randall Goren said disconsolately, pulling at his tie. "It isn't really about tea," his mother, former NYPD detective and squad captain Alexandra Eames Goren, tried to explain again as she gave one final look at herself and her blue flowered-print tea gown in the long mirror. "It's like a nice restaurant," his sister Olivia offered, checking her full-skirted blue-and-violet tartan print dress beside her mother. Randall sighed. "A girl thing." Robert Goren, sharp in a navy-blue suit, pale-blue shirt, and black-and-navy striped tie, chuckled. "Be fair, buddy. They did the escape room with us yesterday morning and hung around Lewis's shop all afternoon while we talked cars. Remember about compromises." "I thought we all enjoyed the escape room, and Mom likes cars," Randall reminded as Bobby straightened his blue tie for him and attempted a last taming of his unruly dark hair, then muttered that he almost would have preferred the American Girl store. "I don't care about dolls," Olivia had retorted loftily. "I'm practically thirteen and I only played with dolls at infants' school." "Thirteen's not much unless you have a bar mitzvah," Randall shrugged, resigning himself to the tie and suit jacket. "Everyone contributed to the wish list," Alex pointed out. "You had the Columbo escape room, sweetie, and we all wanted to visit Lewis. Today, for lunch we're doing Cole's Tea Room, which Min and I chose, and we'll go to Radio City Music Hall." "I know someone there who can get us into parts of the building no one ever sees any longer," Bobby reminded, lastly checking himself out in the mirror. Alex gave him an approving smilehe was growing a full beard out again, and she thought its silvery color gave him a dashing airand lifted the apartment keys from the big Florida seashell next to the front door. "Eames," and the children always smiled in the affectionate way their father still called their mother by her last name, "do you think this new gimmick will help save Cole's?" As he spoke, Bobby shepherded the family out of Steve and Liz Hogan's apartment and made certain the door was locked. Out of nowhere in May, sometime soon after Randall's adoption was finalized, Alex's brother-in-law Stephen announced that it was "high time" he took his wife on a second honeymoon cruise. It was scheduled for late August into early September, and, since St. Gregory's Academy didn't start classes until after Labor Day, he proposed to the Gorens that, while he and Elizabeth were away, they use their apartment; bring their collie and the budgie and spend two weeks in New York City visiting old haunts and old friends. Carlos Serrano lobbied to house-sit and keep alive the little tomato and cucumber plants growing in buckets outside their sun porch, to which they agreed. Their young neighbor and friend had grown even more serious since the February incident where a pedophile ring had spirited away his best friend Tito. Bobby and Alex both knew he was chafing to do something adult to contribute to the family finances (he and his younger sister Luciana were supported by their abuela, Abril Diaz), so they had proposed an acceptable salary, then happily decamped to the Hogan apartment. Wise to her family's ways, Alex had suggested that no one take a book along, since they would probably buy more; predictably, on their first full day, they had spent an afternoon at the Strand near Union Square. She had joked that she would bring her laptop while they lost themselves in the four-story bookstore, but the whole family had found something to read. Now Bobby was carrying a worn paperbound book from 1928 called Frederick's Guide to New York, which had a description of their destination in its heyday. === two days earlier === Alex was sitting in bed absorbed in the newest Scarpetta novel when Bobby appeared in the doorway. He still read to the children at night, although even several of their friends had ventured that they thought either Olivia or Randall would have outgrown the ritual by now, but neither had asked him to stop. They were now dipping into books with more adult themeshe was currently reading A Tree Grows in Brooklyn, totally appropriate for a New York City visit. He watched her read for a few minutes, head bent, hair tied back and draped over her right shoulder, noticing the softness of her expression, glad to see that she looked more relaxed each day. He had worried about her since they returned from SpaceFest; the shock of his being held at gunpoint along with former colleague Lynn Bishop and actor Mason Wagner had an effect that she tried to shrug off, but he could not avoid noticing. During their first week home, she had trouble sleeping, and even now, later in August, at least once a week he felt her restlessly slipping out of bed. The first time, he'd padded in her wake to find her curled on the loveseat in the front parlor with the lamp on low, one of her old favorites in front of her, but she had spent much of the time staring into the fireplace with its bouquet of artificial sunflowers for summer. When she put her book down as if returning to the bedroom, he had raced upstairs, barricading himself in the bathroom with the light on until she was in bed and his breathing was level again. Once he slipped back under the covers, he'd uttered a sleepy murmur and reached for her as if in need of reassurance, and she had burrowed into him for solace. After that, he left her alone, snuggling with her when she returned, and the restlessness had ebbed. Truth be told, he wasn't over the incident, either. The barrel of the Glock haunted him as the punishment room at Tate's had, a small round hole that grew to enormous proportions and swallowed him whole in his dreams. He was talking it out with Dr. Chaudry, as he knew Alex must be, and worried about yet so many other things: Carlos' taciturnity, his failure to hear from Harry Cavanaugh out in Pennsylvania...and Randall's upcoming first day in the Upper School at St. Gregory's. He saw so much of himself in Randallyet Randall was more vulnerable, not having endured the prolonged tempering of infidelity and mental illness, long-term hand-to-mouth, and the ever-present fear of "what if." "Are you even here, Bobby?" Alex asked. She had set the book on the nightstand and was watching him with those steadfast caramel-colored eyes that had borne him through so many crises; he'd dreamed of them when they'd been apart. "Five hundred yard stare," he answered sheepishly, then padded, barefoot, to her side of the bed, and sat at the edge of the mattress, his right hand resting on her thigh under the blanket and sheet. "How does it feel to be home?" She had her hands folded in her lap, the very picture of a model student, her head tilted to the left, thinking of their arrival the previous day, dickering with the garage attendant at the Hogans' building, then transporting their pets and then their suitcases upstairs before emerging into the overheated streets to the nearest market, despite Lizzie having left the refrigerator stocked with milk, juices, covered dishes for their first few nights, loaf cakes and ice cream for dessertseven a box of dog biscuits. "Everything looks the sameand it sure does smell the same." Alex's grin was mischievous, for the overwhelming scent of car exhaust, subway ventilation shafts, cigarettes, trash cans with lids ajar, hot pretzel vendors, and hot metal had been both nostalgic and pungent. "But..." She looked earnestly at him, laying her hand over his, "...but home is with you...and our kids..." Here her eyes twinkled. "...and what Abbi calls 'our little zoo.' We could be in Africa now, or Asia, and I would be home." "Eames," he began, leaning forward, and she did so as well, so their foreheads touched. Unexpectedly, he said, "I'm sorry...about Saunders..." "As if you expected a spoiled TV producer's son to show up with a pistol at a friendly talk to clear the air?" she asked skeptically. "A pistol given him by a mobster's son who probably would have taken the ruby ring he wanted and left him high and dry? You aren't boarding that guilt train again, Agent Goren. I don't want you saying, 'I should have known.'" "Yes, Captain Eames," he responded in mock obedience. "We're here to sightsee and chill," she added as their heads parted. "Definitely sightsee," he agreed, thinking of the previous day. "Papa, why hadn't you ever been to 30 Rock?" Olivia had asked, bemused, when they went to the roof of Rockefeller Center. Thunderstorms had popped up as they ate breakfast and made ready for the day, and the air was rain-washed and clear when they admired the view. Bobby had chuckled, "New Yorkers never go to their own tourist attractions. I lived in Milbury two years before I even hiked up to the mill with your mother." "Sounds weird to me," Randall had said. "We have a week's itinerary already," Alex reminded him now, and her voice took on a secretary's cadence. "Wednesday is lunch at Mama Rosa's with Mike and Carla, museum trip to be decided. Jack, Patty, and Eleanor are going to the zoo with us on Friday, and on Saturday evening we're invited to dinner with Olivia and Noah at the Carisis on Staten Island. Sunday is whatever matinee we can get tickets for, and dinner...somewhere, since Sardi's is closed." "You've forgotten Thursday, O my Captain," he joked. "Have not!" Alex replied with mock indignance. "Mets vs. the Brewers 7:10 p.m. And Monday's the Cloisters and the also the Cathedral of St. John the Divine because Min wants to see the places Madeleine L'Engle wrote about in The Young Unicorns." "Maybe next week we can take them on the ferry, and to Brooklyn," Bobby continued thoughtfully. Alex gave a cat smile. "We'll be very busy. Maybe we ought to think about getting to bed." He laid a soft kiss on her forehead. "I'm not sure I'm sleepy yet. Maybe I'll start the book of treatises on Jung that I bought." She blinked at him and patted the hand still on her thigh. "I don't believe I mentioned sleeping." "Jung will just have to get old, then," he chuckled. . . . . . "Is that what you think, that Cole's revival of the Tea Room is only a gimmick?" Alex asked, tucking the apartment keys into her purse. Years ago, Bobby had explained to the kids, back when New York City had numerous department stores, most women didn't work, so they would go to these stores to shop, meet friends, and even have their hair done, eat at a store luncheonette, visit a store exercise room, or see a fashion show. Some department stores even had a special restaurant just for women shoppers, often called a tea room. It would be a chic place with soft music playing in the background, shining white tablecloths and napkins, bone china teacups and silver spoons and forks, and often they would have food specialties: ice cream sundaes, for instance, or hot muffins. "A gimmick I hope workseither that or Cole's goes the way of Gimbels, Sears, Wanamaker's , and A. T. Stewart." "Sears was never a proper department store," Alex scoffed, but she understood. The two last bastions of the old-guard department stores, with books, stationery, sewing notions, and more, and not just glorified clothing and shoe stores like Saks and Bergdorf's, Macy's and Cole's were what remained in the city, and Cole's barely had its head above water. The new investors, a consortium of Japanese and Saudi Arabian partners, had just sunk a small fortune into remodeling the aged "cast iron" emporium. In the end, the idea of ice cream and muffins finally tipped the scales for Randall, and he was more cheerful by the time they hit the subway. He was now into the boyish "growing phase," and the way he attacked his meals even impressed Bobby. "At least Cole's has rustled up some American investors," Alex remarked as they waited on the subway platform. "Ginkou/Masaaref offered just about everyone a piece of the pie. Bill Gates and Bezos skipped on it, I heard," Bobby agreed, "but the Mulroneys have taken a sharethey wouldn't have dared if Regina Mulroney was still at the family helmand Lydia de Ruysch supposedly has invested enough that she's on the store's board of directors. Rumor is that she's running the show for Ginkou/Masaaref." Randall asked, "You mean there's a real person named Lydia de Ruysch?" "You know the name?" Randall looked abashed. "Well, remember my dad told Mommy and me that he worked on Wall Street? He would talk about these people he worked with, and the one he mentioned most was Lydia de Ruysch. I remember it because it was such a funny name. But after the trial, I figured he just made up the names." "Definitely not made up. The de Ruysch family goes back to New York's founding European colonizers, the Dutch. They arrived soon after Peter Minuit and his ilk. The family were bankers in the Netherlands, and they're still big players in the New York financial market. She's taken a personal interest in Cole's. She wants to make it as it was in its heyday of the 1910s through 1940s." "How did she put it in that Face to Face interview last month? 'The elegance of Art Nouveau with the immediacy of the Web.'" Alex chuckled. "She won't win any Oscars for original dialog." "She's not stuffy like that awful Mr. Copeland, is she?" Olivia asked, her head turning this way and that as the subway platform became more crowded. She was the extrovert of the pair of children, and, even after her early upbringing in Paris, she still marveled at the contrasts: well-worn baseball caps and saggy pants on some, elegant turbans and brilliantly patterned robes on others, proud women in fake furs and long elegant nails, diffident businessmen in similar dark suits and power ties with fiscal assets in their eyes and briefcases dangling from their fists; raucous teens and shy preschoolers, nannies and Con Ed workmen, diplomats and sad-eyed drug addictsall the warp and woof that made up the fabric of New York City. They moved so much faster than Parisians! Even the scent was different: errant exhaust fumes, heated metal, excavated earth, the musky scent of marijuana, with an overlay of earthier ones. "Lydia de Ruysch? Oh, no, she's more like...remember Jeffrey Copeland's aunt Danielle from the book conference? Jeffrey introduced her to us just before we left for home." "Oh, yeah," Randall recalled. "She was nice. Remember? She said she had a boyfriend named Randall in high school." "And you were so embarrassed," Alex returned fondly. "Well, Lydia is the same. She supports social causesthe LGBTQ Defense Fund, for instanceand also law enforcement improvements. I met with her several times when I worked on the Joint Taskforce. She’s on several city upgrade committees and is working with the new mayor." "Here comes our train," Bobby interrupted, and, after a crowd spilled from the line of cars onto the subway platform and headed for the stairs, he and Alex inched their way into the subway car, the children cocooned between them. Randall was uneasy in overcrowded situations, so Alex rode herd on him to make certain he didn't become uncomfortable. She thought how different it was for their children than it had been for her and Bobby. She remembered riding the subway with only her 12-year-old sister at age seven, and how she and Lizzie navigated just fine. She knew that both Bobby and his late brother had free run of the MTA by age eightbut of course they'd been born "city kids," and the early and mid-70s were a much more innocent time. Even when the crime rates soared in the city in the late 70s, the crimes were usually confined to certain neighborhoods. Warned of pickpockets on the subway, so, with fare money and comic book and candy funds carefully hidden, they were never really frightened. Olivia had ridden the Metro in Paris, of course, but always accompanied by her mother or her nanny, and Randall was a suburban kid, so they kept them close at hand. And even then, from where she stood, Alex could see New York kids riding alone, with musical instruments, reading books, staring at cell phones... "Ma'am," offered a young man in a striking hip-hop t-shirt who was seated near them, "would you like to sit down?" Alex smiled. "Thank you so much, but we only have three stops. You might try the woman behind us..." The woman in question was grateful for the seat, profusely thanking both the polite youth and Alex, and the Gorens were soon at their destination. "And there it is," said Bobby, looking upward as they emerged from the older-style subway station. "It looks like something from Paris!" Olivia enthused. "It certainly doesn't look like the same place," Alex marveled as people circled them while they admired the building that had changed radically since they had stopped living in the city. The last time Alex had seen Cole's regularly, before her retirement, the gracefully arched windows were blocked with dirty screens or vintage, faded-green window shades, some perpetually obscured by vinyl banners promoting the store's website, and the marble and ironwork exterior was grimy from decades of pollution. It was in the style of A.T. Stewart's original 1846 "Marble Palace," but with Art Nouveau ironwork around the display windows and at the first-floor level, simplified for the upper stories. The exterior had been sandblasted and the ironwork restored. Too, for years anachronistic modern doors had replaced the originals at the store's three entrances, giving the vintage building an ugly, patchwork appearance. Now, lighter, automatic reproductions of the original Art Nouveau doors, with their gently coiling lily branches and blooms, returned the redesigned building to its classic appearance. All the ironwork had been retouched with colored and gold metallic highlights, and the Cole's logo, the top hat and walking stick as familiar as the Macy's star, was cleaned and restored. Outside on the lampposts and on each of the exterior doors hung a poster swirled with carmine red, ultramarine blue, and palest silver, the Cole's top hat/walking stick logo in black centered upon it, and on top, in swooping calligraphy in white, "Cole's Resurgens." "That's Latin," Olivia said instantly. "It means 'rebirth,'" Bobby confirmed. "Ms. de Ruysch and her conglomerate are determined to bring the place back to life." Inside, the store certainly looked reborn. The limp 60s and 90s upgrades were gone, and, while the interior walls were more clean-lined than in 1910, as many of the vintage dark wooden-framed display cases as possible had been returned to service to give the first floor a classic look. Faux Art Nouveau lanterns supplemented the recessed modern lighting with energy-efficient LED bulbs providing warm light. To make the store as striking as possible upon entry, Cole's had positioned the jewelry and watch departments, with their glitter and attraction, at the center of the main floor. Expensive gold, sterling silver, and precious gemstone pieces were featured on one side; less expensive costume jewelry and more-reasonably priced timepieces and smartwatches were displayed on the other. Randall tugged at Olivia's arm, pointing wordlessly at a Rolex Cosmograph Daytona "Rainbow" watch priced at $450,000.00. "I saw one of those in Galleries Lafayette once. You could buy a house in Maine like Donna and Zes have for that," Olivia whispered in amazement. With the publicity over the redesign and reopening of many departments, the store was very busy, with salespersons in business dress helping customers. They rode the original wooden escalators up to each floor, checking out the fresh new decorations, the retro lighting, and the vintage touches among clothing, housewares and appliances, electronics and hardware, finally past the huge book, toy, and stationery departments, and up to the top floor, most of which was executive and business offices, but where a portion was reserved for the tea room and its adjacent kitchen, from which savory scents arose. Both children were used to "fine dining" from Mother's Day and Alex's birthday, when dress clothing and "Sunday manners" were de rigueur, but even Randall looked around "The Olive Tree" tea room with his mouth parted. The far side of the tea room overlooked the main street, and the wooden-framed, arched windows had surrounds of copperwork Art Nouveau olive trees. The windows themselves had remotely operated modern shades, seamlessly blending the two eras. Plush burgundy rugs with olive-green olive branches inset into the pile, and cozy square wooden tables covered with snow-white tablecloths and napkins folded into simulated mountain peaks dotted the room. The place settings were of ironware with sturdy silverware and tall tumblers. The round-backed chairs, four to a table, had woven backrests. Opposite the windows, on a long wall, Parisian-style Art Nouveau posters hung in gold frames between plush olive-and-cream drapery, and long wooden tables with inlaid tops (for use at the Sunday buffet, Alex whispered) lined the wall, alternating with tall jardinieres filled with fresh gladioli stems. Two square Doric columns divided the room into three sections. Now a server approached the window table the maitre d' had assigned them. She was tall, with a tawny complexion and thick, dark hair pulled back into a neat bun, and a little frilled cap perched over her forehead. She wore a bright olive-green, full-skirted uniform dress, with a full, ruffled white apron over it, and unobtrusive black orthopedic shoes in a 1930s eyelet style over black stockings. "Good afternoon," she greeted them warmly, distributing imitation-leather-bound menus. "Welcome to the Olive Tree at Cole's. This is our luncheon menu. Our specialties today are scratch-made chicken pot pie and the Brittany truffle omelette. I will return in a few minutes with rolls and butter. It's a warm day, but would anyone care for coffee or tea?" Alex ordered a tea and Bobby a coffee, and the server bustled away to inquire of the needs of two women just being seated several tables away. Bobby flipped open his 1928 Frederick's guide and read, "'A singular treat for any New York visitor is to sample the delectable dishes available at the "tea room" of Cole's Department Store. Belying its twee name, the establishment offers sustenance for both hearty eaters and dainty appetites; the specialties of the house include a savory chicken pot pie filled with moist slices of white and dark meat, julienne-cut carrots and potatoes, and a thick gravy under an exquisitely flaky crust, and Chef Malinois' authentic Brittany truffle omelette, a light but filling meal that includes imported French truffles and fresh eggs directly from Sullivan County farms.' "Seems today's specials are the classics," he concluded. "Although I doubt the eggs come from Sullivan County any longer. Their farm is probably a half-dozen subdivisions by now," Alex responded wryly. The menu was a charming combination of vintage favoritessalmon croquettes, chicken à la king, olive loaf and flaked salmon sandwiches along with the pot pie and truffle omeletteand newer items such as open-faced roast beef and turkey served over baked-on-the-premises brioche bread, plus chicken tenders as a children's option, all printed in sepia ink on "aged" paper. "Please tell me you won't order chicken tenders," Olivia murmured to Randall. "But I like them," he protested. "But the chicken pot pie sounds wonderful, like Papa's chicken stew under a flaky crust! And no peas in it sound even better." Olivia ate peas, but she considered them not much more appetizing than the hated green beans. "The truffle omelette sounds very tempting," Alex mused. "What's a salmon croquette?" Olivia asked. "Think of the crab cakes we ate in Mystic," Bobby advised. "Made with flaked salmon and an egg binder, then breaded and fried." "Unless you grew up on a strict budget the way we did," Alex reminded with a grin, "where they were made with chicken and stretched out with mashed potatoes." "I've tried to blot those from my memory," Bobby said, making a face. The waitress returned with rolls and butter, and took their orders. Soon they had been servedRandall dug into a chicken pot pie as did his sister and declared it good, and Alex and Bobby traded forkfuls of truffle omelet and open-faced turkey while the children looked embarrassed at their parents feeding each otherand were almost finished when a pleasant woman's voice exclaimed disbelievingly, "Alexandra Eames? Is that you?" Alex turned, then smiled broadly at the middle-aged blonde approaching the table, her surprised face melting into a welcoming grin. "It is you! My goodness! I haven't seen you in..." "About ten years," Alex finished, rising to greet her. Bobby stood as well, well trained in manners by his mother, but Olivia had to shove Randall's foot under the table as a reminder before he gave up his fork and rose respectfully. "Oh, my goodness, no," the woman said chattily, "please sit down and finish your meal, and I hope it's everything you hoped it would be." "It's delicious, ma'am," confirmed Olivia, bobbing her head up and down. "I could eat another one," Randall confessed. The woman appeared delighted. "Please sityou don't mind if I bring a chair over and sit a few minutes? I have a dozen things to do, but I had to say hello, Alex!" The maitre d' hurried from out of nowhere to bring her a chair from an empty table. The stranger settled next to Alex, a plump woman with very long blond hair braided at the back of her head, pale blue eyes, and a finely made-up face, her hands dotted with dainty rings, including a large diamond solitaire, and her nails professionally done. She had the air of someone who knew the finer things in life but was not haughty about them; even Bobby could see that, although her retro-style dress and shoes were casual, they were not cheaply made, and diamond teardrops swayed from her earlobes. "This is my friend Lydia de Ruysch," Alex introduced, "as I think you've gathered, and Lydia, this is my family: my husband Robert Goren," and Bobby, still standing, extended a hand across the table to shake before sitting down again, "and our daughter Olivia and our son Randall." "I'm happy to meet you all," Lydia said in a musical voice. "It was always such a pleasure working with Alex, even though it didn't happen very often. But I don't remember you being married the last time we worked togetherhow times change!" Alex bit her lip, her eyes on the tablecloth for a second before they came back up dancing. "Well, I retired a year after we last talked, and things...happened once I moved to Connecticut..." Bobby's eyebrows twitched as she pinked and continued, "Bobby and I ran into each other againwe'd worked together ten years earlierand things...just fell into place." De Ruysch's indulgent smile told them she could piece together the rest of that portion of the story. "The children were...a happy surprise, though," Bobby said with affection, patting Olivia's hand. "A friend of ours and her...partner...lost their lives in a car accident, and in her will she asked that we be Olivia's guardians. And Randall was our foster son until May, when we made it official." Alex met Randall's eyes, and she added softly, "They truly have been a blessing." Then she spread her hands and enthused, "Lydia, this is all so beautiful. I can't believe what a difference you've made to this old place. Please, tell us what's been going on!" So as the children finished their lunches and they all ordered dessert"What's parfait?" Randall whispered to his sister, only for her face to light up. "Trust me, you'll like it!"de Ruysch launched into a waterfall of words about working with the investors, trying to balance affordable refurbishment against the desire to restore each floor as accurately as possible, fitting modern technology into the vintage look, and recruiting out-of-work craftsmen from the Workforce Development Program to recreate architectural details while giving them much-needed employment. Olivia and Randall mostly concentrated on the huge parfaits with their layers of whipped cream, chocolate ice cream, mini chocolate chips, and sliced strawberries. The maitre d' came with their check, but de Ruysch waved him away with, "Emile, this meal is comped." Alex valiantly protested, but de Ruysch argued that it was a thank you for the help Alex had provided long ago. Randall had taken the opportunity to use the restroom, so that the two women were still chatting when an older woman's exasperated voice stopped de Ruysch in mid-word. "Lyddie, dearest! For heaven's sake, I've been calling you for over an hour." De Ruysch's face had the weary expression of one forced to deal with the impossible, but she apologized, "I'm sorry, Tante Marika, but I ran into an old friend. I could not be impolite." Her smile was strained, but she added formally, "Tante Marika, this is my old friend Alexandra Eames, whom I worked with some years in the past, and this is her husband, Mr. Robert Goren, and their daughter Olivia." Olivia rose from her chair, along with her parents, at the woman's approach; she was reminded so much of her late father's formidable wife, Madame Pepin, that she involuntarily curtsied. Their hostess added, "Their son Randall is in the rest room," then finished hastily, "This is my aunt, Marikje Van Amstel." "Pleased to meet you," Mrs. Van Amstel declared in a voice that would have chilled champagne. Despite her age, which Alex estimated as early 70s, she was a slim, athletic woman with a cap of hair that could only be described as "salt and pepper," and an oval face with a pointed chin, alert grey eyes under meticulously plucked eyebrows, a slim nose, and a prim mouth. Her complexion alone told the world she took rigorous care of her skin and not with drugstore products. To complete the effect, she was clad in a Saint Laurent suit and silk blouse in shades of amber, a genuine fur stole around her shoulders despite the summer heat, and classic Christian Louboutin pumps. The only aspect of her appearance that made her look the least bit approachable was the fluffy, inquisitive-nosed golden Pomeranian she carried, and even he was imposing, with a collar that looked as if it were studded with genuine diamonds. "Since I was passing by Cole's," and the very way she spoke told them she had deliberately stopped by to call her out her niece as well as talk to her, "I wanted to let you know I won't be available for our customary dinner on Thursday. I'm taking Flounce," and the Pom wagged its tail, "and my assistant to the cottage in Tannersville through Sunday evening. I find I have some business to attend to in the area, and will be visiting friends as well." "We'll see you next week, then, Tante Marika," de Ruysch said, nodding. "Is there anything I can help with while you're away?" "I take care of my own," Mrs. Van Amstel returned, "you know that, Lyddie. It was a pleasure to meet you, Mr. and Mrs. Goren. Child. Good-bye," and she nodded regally to everyone and turned on her heel, tap-tap-tapping her way back to the elevator. De Ruysch was crimson and stammered, "I a-am s-s-so sorry...she can be...formidable." Alex had watched Lydia de Ruysch work calmly and competently with every type of person, from the previous no-nonsense mayor to flighty actors doing promotional gigs for the city, and had never seen her so discomfited. Bobby offered mildly, "We can't pick our relatives, Lydia. Don't worry about it." Now Randall padded up, wide-eyed. "I waited until the coast was clear, in the door to the bathroom. 'Livia, was that what your Dragon Lady was like?" "Randall," Alex reproved, "that isn't polite." "I think she could give Madame...uh" Olivia was still staring down the corridor leading to the elevators. "a run for her money?" Bobby suggested. Olivia nodded and sat down; it wasn't often that people left her at a loss for words. De Ruysch laughed ruefully. "Randall has a point. Tante Marika can be off-putting. But really, she's just very old-fashioned, a lady-of-the-manor type. Like Penelope Keith's character in To the Manor Born, harmless." Then she sighed and sat back down. "I'm sorry to say I'm grateful that she's not a blood relative. She's my late uncle'smy mother's brother'ssecond wife. Very old money, older than the Knickerbockers, and equally old-school and opinionated. She doesn't understand why I devote so much time to what she calls my 'goody two-shoes' projects. She has her specific charities and feels that's enough, although she's unbent enough to head and sponsor the Cole's Christmas toy drive this year." She eyed Olivia sheepishly as they rose from the table. "This world needs more powerful womenbut not her type of static power. One needs to change with the times." She paused, her eyes troubled. "I'm sorry this luncheon had such a bad ending." "It hasn't been a bad ending at all," Alex countered firmly, and hugged her. "We were able to chat and you met Bobby and the kids. Just a blip in our day." "Will you still be here next Thursday, and if so, will you come for luncheon?" de Ruysch entreated. "We're having a fashion show luncheon, 'Casual Days' we're calling itmen's and women's casual fashions," she added when she saw Randall's pained look, "with special treatschocolate mousse parfaits and raffle prizes. And half the proceeds go to the New York ASPCA. Please. It's at noon, and there's no need to dress up. The food will be buffet style. I'll make sure you get invitations." Bobby tilted his head at Randall, who bowed his head, then came up smiling. "We'd love to," Alex accepted, pulling her son to her side for a hug. . . . . . Wednesday went off without a hitch. Lunch at Mama Rosa's with Mike and Carla Logan was always "brill," as Olivia termed it, and they had then lingered until closing time at the Museum of Natural History. Thursday morning, they had a reservation to go to the top of the Empire State Building, followed by an exploration of small shops, and that evening they were at Citi Field for the Mets game. The children brought books, which Bobby and Alex expected. Still, each time a potentially interesting play occurred, Bobby would explain what options the players had, and why a particular decision was made. Olivia listened with polite interestshe absorbed knowledge of any kind, like a spongebut Randall also quietly observed how much his parents enjoyed the game. As the first half of the seventh inning ended, Randall whispered, "Dad, I gotta pee." "Well," Bobby chuckled, "you've picked the best time," and they headed for the men's room as the organist struck up "Take Me Out to the Ball Game" for the seventh-inning stretch. Randall blinked at the line for the ladies' room and whispered, "Glad I'm not a girl." "And the restroom designers never learn, according to your mother," was the response. "You want to wait for a stall?" Randall took a deep breath. "No, sir. I'll do it. I've been practicing." Bobby tilted his head at him. "Um..." Randall stretched himself up near Bobby's ear and said in a hushed voice, "Against the fence in the back yard, where no one can see because of the bushes. There are urinals in the Upper School, and I don't want to look like a dork" Bobby bit back a smile and patted his shoulder. "That's cool. Just remember...um, eyes on your business." "That's what Carlos said." The short line advanced as he spoke. "Dad, I don't think our team is doing really well tonight." "We're here for the experience, not for the win." Bobby arched his eyebrows. "And I've been mentioning the plays to you because...well, when the other ninth graders talk baseball, you won't be in the dark." "And not look like such a dork," finished Randall. "Thanks, Dad." "Take Me Out to the Ball Game" and the traditional "Lazy Mary" had played during their sojourn, and as they emerged, the announcer came on the loudspeaker. "Ladies and gentlemen, your attention please. We'd like to observe a moment of silence for a great lady who passed on this week, the talented, loving, and generous Dolly Parton. Please join me now in tribute to a truly outstanding entertainer and humanitarian." In the relative quiet that followed, Randall said in a small voice, "Dad, would you and Mom have liked me to play baseball?" Bobby looked down at him with furrowed brow. "Why do you ask, buddy?" The boy shrugged. "You and Mom have a lot of fun watching." "We do. It's fun for us." He faced Randall and put his hands on his shoulders. "But it's not fun for you. You do what you want, what's fun for you. That makes us happy." Randall relaxed, and they quietly finished the moment of silence. Then the announcer continued, "Ladies and gentlemen, tonight, in tribute to the great Dolly Parton, we're going to play a song that's one of our favorites. We urge you to please sing along, because we all live this one every weekday." The driving, percussive beats of the intro made Bobby smile. "C'mon, this is a fun one. We'll want to sing along." "Why?" "You'll understand when you're older." "Tumble out of bed and I stumble to the kitchen Alex stood to let them in, but Bobby tugged her toward the open steps instead. No one was coming from either directionindeed, there were already people on the stairs clapping and dancingand he grinned. "Let's dance." And they did, as the children laughed and the music continued and they sang along, "Jump in the shower and the blood starts pumpin' "Workin' 9 to 5, what a way to make a livin'..." . . . . . "Thanks for the ride!" Olivia Benson said with a smile as she and her son Noah took their seats in the second row of the Honda Pilot. "I checked the traffic on the BQE and it appears to be behaving itself today." "I hope so," Alex replied tartly, pulling out into traffic, "because I'm way out of practice." Olivia leaned forward in her seat, her face glowing. "Hi, Noah!" "Hey," and she was disappointed in the stunted response. Noah Porter-Benson had his dark, curly head bent over his phone, rapidly typing with his thumbs. "Noah," Benson chided gently, "I know you didn't want to miss the tournament today, but we've had this planned over a month. Can't you come up for air for a little while?" "I will, Mom," Noah answered, but there was a slight impatience in his voice, "once we get to Uncle Sonny's folks' place. Right now Pete and Stan are keeping me updated on the scores." Bobby asked from the front passenger seat, "Is this a sports event?" "Gaming!" Noah replied eagerly. "It's a new competition game called Doomscroller. My friends from school and I are really into it." "You're playing Doomscroller?" Randall asked, brightening. "My friend Samuel at school plays that." "It's a really sick game," and Noah continued promoting the game's attributes while still keeping his eyesand thumbsfirmly on the phone. Alex glanced in the rearview mirror and caught a glimpse of Olivia's face. Noah had been one of the first children Olivia had met when Alex and Bobby had brought the heartsick and homesick child home from Paris. She felt a kinship to him because they were both adopted, and for a long time she'd had a little crush on him as well. The latter had mellowed into a strong friendship, although Alex recalled with a little pang that Olivia had commented that Noah's formerly frequent e-mails had become scarce of late. She looked sideways at Bobby and was half-amused that he looked ready to remove the phone from Noah's handsbut then Bobby was always sensitive to Olivia's emotions. But even Bobby, she knew, couldn't keep years from passing and old friends from changing. Olivia settled back in her seat, lowering her gaze to her phone. Randall signed to her. = R U OK? = Olivia replied chattily, hoping for a reaction, "I'm working on my fanfiction. I want it ready to post when I get my invitation to AO3." "I'll beta read it for you," Randall offered. Noah didn't take the bait, and Olivia kept her sigh to herself. To alleviate the silence, Benson asked, "How was the Bronx Zoo? I hear they've reopened the World of Darkness exhibit." "Oh, that was sick!" Randall enthused. "There were vampire bats!" "We saw the Przewalski's horses, too," Olivia said a bit diffidently, then did chuckle, "And a goat in the farmyard tried to eat Aunt Patty's purse." Noah made it all the way to Staten Island seemingly oblivious to the rift he had caused. Alex finally turned left from Arden Avenue to arrive at the brick home of Dominick and Serafina Carisi, but Benson and her son hung back at the car for slightly longer. When Noah finally entered the house, his phone was shoved in his pocket, and he didn't take it out again. Inside the house was controlled bedlam; it wasn't a small house, but neither was it a "McMansion," and it was full to bursting. Dominick "Sonny" Carisi's and Amanda Rollins' two little girls, Jesse and Billie, came running up to hug Olivia and Randallthe last time they had met was at Randall's adoption hearingand all three of Sonny's sisters were there, including Gina, the youngest, whom the Gorens had never met. With the crowd there, it was difficult to find their male hostDominick Senior, who was a stockier, darker version of his ADA son, was offering grappa to his son-in-law and a male cousin next to fold-out card tables and folding chairs in the den. But it wasn't difficult at all to find Serafina, who was in the kitchen with oldest daughter Bella and granddaughter Mia monitoring the food that was bursting from all corners of the black-and-white tiled kitchen that hadn't changed in years: pasta boiling on the stove, sauce simmering on the back burner, the scent of lasagna from the oven, and two big bowls of mixed green salad and a big tray of antipasto filled with prosciutto, provolone cheese, green and black olives, and anchovies on the counters. In the floral-wallpapered dining room, the table was already fully extended with all its leaves, and extra folding chairs filled the empty spaces. A second table was set against the far wall, with more folding chairs. Serafina greeted Benson with a big hug, and Benson laughed. "Serafina, you seem to have cornered the market on folding chairs." "They're from Fabrizzi's Funeral Home," explained Serafina. "They're basically chair supply central in this neighborhood. Did you see Nicky yet? Dominick has him somewherehe gets into everything now. I told him to get him away from the kitchen." "Nicky's three now, right?" Bobby asked. "Last month. And the apple of his nonna's eye," Serafina glowed. She had her silvering blond hair pulled back in a bun while she was cooking, and wore a black apron over her light dress, one which proclaimed, "I am an Italian woman. I was born with my heart on my sleeve, a fire in my soul, and a mouth I can't control." "Nonna," Mia called. "The sauce is done." "It's done when I say it's done," Serafina countered. "Shoo. A few more minutes. Go find Dominick." They found Sonny Carisi in the rear hallway with a three-year-old overstimulated by all the "company"Nicky, in shorts and a little t-shirt proclaiming "Thank God I'm Italian" over an Italian flag, was running up and down singing "Old Macdonald Had a Farm," but only singing the pig verse, with his pig grunts sounding more like farts. They watched him for a few minutes, laughing, then Bobby grabbed him and lifted him in the air. "Winnah and new cham-peen!" Nicky gurgled in delight. "Lift me up, up!" and Bobby held him up until he could touch the ceiling with his small fingers. "Yippee!" His mother Amanda came bustling out of her mother-in-law's bedroom. Looking up, she laughed. "Okay, buster, now that you're the tallest one in the room, it's time for the trip down to get cleaned up for dinner." "No," Nicky insisted. "Up, up! The big man makes me go up, up!" "Elevator's coming down," Bobby told him to his disappointment. "Go with your mom and we'll do 'up, up' laterbut only if you're nice at Nonna's dinner." Nicky pouted. "Okay," he finally said, and Amanda, laughing, led him away. "Whew," Carisi breathed, mopping his forehead with a handkerchief. Even in a polo shirt and light trousers, he was red from exertion and sweating. "I don't need a gym with the little guy around." "I can see that," Benson answered tartly, but hugged him despite his rumpled appearance. "Hey, c'mere," and he motioned them toward the far end of the hallway. "Ma will kill me if I talk shop at her dinner, but I wanted you guys to know that I got a call from my contact at the Center for Missing and Exploited Children. They think they have leads on the group that got Carlos' buddy in February." Randall's eyes lit up. "They've found Tito?" "No," Carisi apologized. "Not even that close, Rand. I'm sorry. I know Mrs. De Castro and Carlos are going through a tough time. But this is more info than we've had in months. We just need to...cross fingers. Pray that there's more soon." "It's a positive step," Alex encouraged, for Randall's joy had been snuffed out and even Olivia had her head bowed. "Okay, okay!" Dominick Senior announced, emerging from the den. "Serafina sent me in here to tell you everything's ready. The tables in the den are for the young folks," and he smiled broadly at Olivia and Randall, "so we old fogies don't bore you, and if the rest of you will make your way to the dining room, Serafina's ready to fill your mouths with some cibo squisito!" "Come on, everyone," his wife called from the kitchen, "or the lasagna will get all mushed!" "My God," Amanda laughed, emerging from the bedroom with Nicky, his face washed and a big bib over his colorful shirt, "that's the same thing she said when I ate here the first time!" Olivia whispered to Randall, "Betcha can't eat everything Mrs. Carisi dishes up." Randall looked at her sideways. "Bet I can." . . . . . "There! Four rush seats!" Alex declared triumphantly, saving the QR code on her phone. "But not for Hamilton," Olivia mourned. "I’m sorry, Min. We couldn't swing that in the budget," was the regretful answer. "What's an Operation Mincemeat?" Randall asked. Olivia observed, "It sounds like Christmas, but I think it's historical." "Your cue, Professor Goren," Alex said with amusement, and Bobby launched into an explanation of the World War II-era decoy dead body which had thrown the Nazis off the scent of where the D-Day landings would be. "And it's a musical?" was Olivia's disbelieving reply. "A very well-reviewed one." Fast-paced, too, they realized later, and Randall missed a bit of the British wordplay, but Olivia whispered translations to him, so they emerged having enjoyed themselves. In consideration of their bruised budget and the huge meal they'd consumed at the Carisi home (Serafina had sent them home with two meals' worth of leftovers), they chose to eat a simple supper at a diner located next to a high-profile French restaurant, Henri. While waiting near the door of the diner for a seat, they watched limousines pull up to the curb to pick up the executives and "beautiful people" leaving the trendy venue. Randall ducked behind Bobby to eye the parade of fashionable New Yorkers and jerked his head up as a pearl-grey classic limousine took its turn at the front. A woman in a familiar fur stole and flowing gown, carrying a little golden Pomeranian, came bustling out of the restaurant with a powerfully built, tall, white-haired man at her side. "Well, look who's back in town," Alex said wryly as the chauffeur helped Mrs. Van Amstel into the vehicle. The white-haired man bid her farewell, bowing and laughingly telling her, "Thank you for the oh-so-special treat, Marikje. Perhaps again next month?" as he smiled into the backseat. It looked as if a younger man sat rigidly next to the driver's side door, with a large valise beside him. His head was shaved, and something was tattooed at the base of his skull where it met the spine. "Stay out of trouble, Jonny!" Van Amstel replied almost coquettishly. "Remember, you are always wanted." "The man in the back seat must be the assistant she mentioned at Cole's," Bobby mused, squinting at the scene until the pearl-grey car pulled away from the curb. "Based on her attitude, I'm surprised it's not some sharp young blonde in a power suit. Somehow her Fifties wardrobe doesn't fit with a hip young dude with a shaved head and ink," Alex replied. "Did the poor guy have to wait in the car while she ate? Hope she brought him a doggy bag." "Did you notice," Bobby observed, "that when she mentioned to Lydia that she was going to Tannersville for the weekend, she mentioned the dog's name, but not her assistant's?" "Goren, booth for four!" called a voice from the doorway, and they hurried inside. Once they were seated and provided with menus, Alex was pushing the salt cellar around with her fingers, the scene outside and Bobby's comment still bothering her. "I've never understood why some of the wealthy have to treat their help so badly," she remarked. "Respect doesn't cost you." "I can say that for Madame," Olivia admitted. "She had her nose in the air, and never liked me, but she treated the servants well." Alex looked at Bobby. "I remember the Davenport case, those two women using their nannies like equipment to be rented. When one of them said, 'Hannah knows her place,' I wanted to smack her." "Which case was that?" Randall asked curiously, and, carefully editing out the more gruesome features of the story, they told the children about two unhappy sisters. Occasionally, Bobby and Alex talked about their old cases, with Randall sitting rapt throughout; Olivia listened, but not as he did, absorbed by the crime and investigation details; instead she paid attention more to what wasn't said: the pauses in an emotional situation and the shared glances as they edited, on the fly, what to tell and what to leave out. Later, as usual, the pair was talking after lights-out, Olivia in Eddie Hogan's old bed and Randall in the fold-up cot. Having dissected the oddball musical and the sensible diner food, Olivia was still pensive about the sisters' tale they had heard at supper. "They were bad for killing people," she reflected, "but their lives started out sad. At least Hannah's did, so she wanted to believe that everything was going to turn out like that telly soap. And Sarah just wanted a big sister." "Dad and Mom tell a lot of stories like that. Remember the woman who was never good enough for her husband? Dad mentioned it again when he explained why I thought I was bad for being weird. It was because my father criticized me so much." "That was sad. I'm glad the little boy went home with his grandmother and not his dreadful father!" Olivia paused, listening to the low hum of television voices from the living room and Bandit scolding. "Back before Mama and Papa were Mama and Papa, I asked him why people killed. He looked sad when he answered menow I know it was because of Maman. He said there were many reasonsanger, revenge, even true evil, but mostly resentment. People felt they were wronged and did it to get back at who hurt thembut even if they were wronged, it wasn't a reason to kill." Randall turned over on his cot to face her. "You ever going to tell Dad that you read the whole thesis?" "It would bother him," she protested. "You won't tell?" Randall promised, "Pinky swear." . . . . . Their plans changed during the Sunday night news; due to rain moving in on Tuesday, they put off the Cloisters/Cathedral visit until that day and hit the Museum of New York City, the Tenement Museum, and the 9/11 Memorial on Monday. Both children had studied the latter event in school and had been eager to go, but seeing genuine artifacts from the event, including twisted beams and the sobering personal effects of the victims, made both Randall and Olivia introspective, the latter even leaning against Bobby as she used to. "Look at this," and she paused at the account of Michael Hingson and his guide dog, Roselle, who led Hingson and others from the North Tower on the day of the attack. The display also mentioned another guide dog, Salty, who had led his owner from the building. "It was a terrible day," Alex said in a tight voice unlike her. "I think we all ran down here to help. By the time both Jack and I arrived, both towers were down. All we could do was triage those who'd made it out. Jack knew at least two dozen firefighters who went up into those towers and never came down." "Another Narcotics guy and I went into a bodega on Houston Street and asked for water to bring down to Ground Zero after the second plane hit. We didn't expect a collapse and knew the rescue workers would need water. He and I and the bodega guySanchezstarted to load them onto pallet trolleys," Bobby related softly. "We were over a mile away, and there were already these...um...ungodly soundsgroaning, metal squealing, creaking like the building was in pain. People were screaming...sirens, car horns, helicopters dispatched from NYPD and FDNY and the news stations...the windows st-started to pop out, you could hear the glass shatter, and sounds like gunshotsrivets in the steel popping loose and the snap of concrete breaking as easily as pretzel sticks...and then more screams and the roar" He was breathing hard and covered his face with a splayed hand. "Me and Hart and Sanchez dived into the bodega behind the counter and held our hands over our ears as it fell. It was like an earthquake I'd been through in Korea." Randall was staring at him. "But the f-firefighters and the p-paramedics and the cops...they went in an-anyway..." "It was our job, sweetie. 'To protect and serve,' as they say." Alex put her arms around Randall's shoulders. "Both of us would have gone in if we'd arrived earlier. Uncle Jack, too. And Captain Benson, and Fin, and Elliot. You do what you have to do." . . . . . Bobby had a contact who knew a staff member at the Cathedral of St. John the Divine, so Olivia was dazzled by a special tour of the space where one of her favorite authors had worked, now the Madeleine L'Engle Library. After a day at the Cloisters looking at medieval treasures, the staff member gave them a tour not only of the library but also of the cathedral itself. They were then seated in a pew for not quite half an hour, listening to the choir practicing for a September 11th 25th-anniversary service. While Olivia's mother had instilled in her a distrust of religion, she still admired the cathedral's artistry and the beautiful music of the pipe organ, and her eyes roved the great arches and embellishments as the voices washed over them, singing of peace. It was thundering as they emerged, and they took a cab back to the Hogan apartment, arriving just before the skies opened. They watched a movie, then retired early. The next day they spent at Coney Island, where it was cloudy and in the seventies, with a snapping, fresh breeze off the Atlantic. They walked the beach, rode the rides, ate hot dogs and French fries at Nedick's, slurped ices, and took refuge in a souvenir shop during a 20-minute rain squall, emerging with refrigerator magnets and salt-water taffy, then returned to finish what was left of the Carisi feast. Randall took only a small square of lasagna and a bowl of salad, and made a face even at that. "I guess I ate too much," he admitted as he picked at the olives with a fork. "After all those hot dogs, I'm not surprised," Alex said with a smile. "Just eat the salad, if you can." "Save your appetite for the chocolate mousse parfait tomorrow," Olivia reminded. . . . . . "Look at that," Olivia beamed, holding the striking garment up, "you can wear it first day of school! You'll be the best-looking ninth-grader in St. Greg's. And it'll bring out the green in your eyes." Randall tried to pretend he didn't like his raffle prize, a glossy hunter-green button-down short-sleeved boy's shirt and walnut-colored trousers, but inwardly he knew Olivia was right. She whispered mischievously in his ear, "Maybe Katy Sherman will notice you more." "Katy" Alex began curiously, then bit back a smile as Randall turned red. "She has brown hair and freckles, and she's a math whiz," Olivia explained. "A lot of the boys fancy her, even the older ones" She made a face. "and that's cringe, but she talks to Randall sometimes, just about schoolwork, though." Bobby whispered to Alex, "Your turn," remembering how she had teased him when Leo crushed on Olivia, and he had protested that she was too young. She glared back, and Olivia, taking advantage of the good humor, asked wheedlingly, "While they're doing the adult raffle, may Rand and I go downstairs to the book department? Then you can come downstairs to fetch us." "We remember the rules," Randall spoke up. "'Don't' everything." "After what happened at SpaceFest," Olivia reminded severely, "maybe we should have rules for you." They had to laugh at that, and sent the pair off. Olivia admitted later that they didn't just look at the books; for them, that entire floor of Cole's was a veritable feast. The greeting cards, engraved stationery, and journals and pens were at one end of the floor, the toys and games at the other, with the book department in the center. They exited the elevator and made a circuit of the floor, Olivia snapping photos of journals, pen sets, and card games that they found interesting as suggestions for birthday and Christmas gifts. They also noticed the "short staffing" Lydia de Ruysch had fretted over before the "Casual Days" event began. As the summer ended, Cole's was facing an employee shortage as high schoolers and college students headed back to classes, and Human Resources had not yet refilled the slots. They appeared to be the only ones on the floor, except for the lone salesperson restocking the card racks, who pushed a cart toward the service elevators just as they finished their circuit. Ms. de Ruysch had explained that they had also pulled several employees from less busy departments to fill in at the Tea Room event. The toy department was similarly deserted; Randall stopped to ask the single salesperson about the Doomscroller card game, but received only half an answer before there was a crash from behind one of the swing doors at the rear and the man excused himself to see what had happened. They left the aisles of books, tall overhead as in the library, until last. The book department was partitioned from the other two areas by whimsical half-walls with archways and lattice fencing interwoven with artificial vines, creating the effect of a gardenindeed, the archway into the department proclaimed it "The Book Arbor." Here, too, the shelves were being restocked, but carts stacked with books sat unattended in corners. "They have a brill selection," Olivia said, surprised, as they wandered up and down the surprisingly numerous aisles. "It's like a regular book shop! What's that book?" "Just one of those vampire things," Randall replied dismissively from where he'd halted in front of a purple-and-black cardboard "book dump." The cover of the trade paperback featured a preteen girl in a long gown; her smile revealed pointed canine teeth, each one piercing her lower lip and raising a pearl of metallic red. White lettering at the top proclaimed "70th anniversary edition," and then the title in blood red, Darkness Takes a Daughter. "It might be something spooky to read for Halloween!" Olivia took a snapshot of it. "Philip!" a woman's voice called from the toy portion of the floor. "Philip Socia! Are you here? I've been told you're on duty today." Olivia made a face. "Oh, no." "Philip?" called the woman again. She sighed, "It's Ms. de Ruysch's snooty aunt." Randall winced. "Hope she doesn't come looking at books. Maybe we ought to go" "I'm here, Mrs. Van Amstel," a smooth older man's voice responded. "How nice to see you. Hello, Mr. Ramirez." "Hello, Mr. Socia," came a throaty, younger male voice. Olivia had already begun to retreat, but Randall froze in place, then stepped quickly to stop her, whispering, "Let's see where she is." The man named Philip chuckled. "I've never seen such a serious young man as you, Manuel. Smile sometime. Enjoy life." "Of course, sir," and "the serious young man" managed his own chuckle. "Don't worry, I give Manuel sufficient time for pleasure," Mrs. Van Amstel said in an indulgent voice. "In fact, we were just at the country house this weekend. Now, the reason I wanted to talk to you, Philip, was this year's Christmas toy drive. I thought hard before accepting the responsibility, but I'll take pride in heading up the event. I understood they didn't start until after Labor Day last year, so I want to get an early start this year.” "Certainly, ma'am," Philip responded. "Would you like to chat about it in my office?" Randall had tugged his sister next to one of the lattice-and-vine partitions where they could peek through without being seen. Olivia stared for a moment, then poked him. "Is that..." she asked, surprised. "Shhh," he said, barely audible. "That would be fine," Mrs. Van Amstel answered brightly. They saw her turn to her assistant and say rather playfully, "But the three of us certainly won't fit in Philip's tiny office. You stay here with Flounce and my bags, Manuel, and I'll be just a few minutes." She flashed him an almost mischievous smile. "Now, you won't run away, will you?" "Of course not, Madam," was the light response. Olivia looked at Randall, something about the exchange making her uneasy. She pulled him back further down, where they could still see, but not be as close. "It's...Tito, isn't it? I s'pose he could shave his head, but Tito didn't have pierced eyebrows or a septum ring. But why does she call him 'Manuel'?" They watched through the lattice-and-vines as Van Amstel walked away laughing on Philip Socia's arm, while the young man known as Manuel Ramirez remained at attention, his face expressionless, his watchful eyes on the place where his employer had vanished. The Pomeranian Flounce was half-asleep in his right arm, and he could have set the shopping bags down, but he did not. Randall stared out between the vines, swallowing hard. "It is him. With his head shaved, you can really see his scar. He fell on a balcony rail when he and Carlos were playing. I think when they were ten. They stitched it at the ER, but it left that knotty-looking scar. I saw it real close the night I stayed with Carlos when Aunt Abbi was away. Carlos teased that if it wasn't for the knot, Tito could have been a male model." "Papa said it, when he talked about the traffickers," Olivia whispered, horrified. "They hurt him so much that now he does whatever she wants. He won't run away because he thinks she'll find him and punish him. I didn't know talking to her" "Dad said that, too, that you wouldn't know. And Tito has no one to trust" Then Randall swallowed hard, and his next words spilled out as if from a faucet. "'Livia, make sure you watch me, but move back some more and call Mom and Dad. Tell them to come quick, then call Captain Benson. You've got her private number to talk to Noah. Tell her to get to Cole's quick or send Fin or Amanda or somebody. Go! Don't let the Dragon Lady see you!" And he pushed her backward and vanished between the shelves. Startled, she could only stare after him, then she pressed herself against the trellis and peered through the vines. "Manuel" was still standing at attention, eyes fixed on Van Amstel's last position. Then Randall appeared, somewhat wild-eyed, and was beside him. "Tito, come on. Come w-with me. It's okay. 'Livia and I are h-here. We can help y-you." "Manuel" was unmoved. Randall's voice took on a frantic note. "Tito, it's me, R-Randall. Mom and Dad are here. They're c-coming in just a minute. They'll help you." Now the older boy's eyes blinked. "Please go away." Olivia roused herself, turning down the ringer on her phone and calling Alex. No one picked up. Voicemail. She hung up and dialed Bobby. Now the phone popped up an "out of service" message. Frantically, she pressed the shortcut to Alex's phone again. Voicemail. "Mama, hurry, come please. And Papa. Tito's here. Rand's trying to get him to run away, but he won't go. Oh, please, oh, please." Shouldn't she go upstairs to find someone? But that would mean leaving Randall alone...non, non... She looked up to see Randall tugging on "Manuel's" sleeve, heard him pleading, and then the same toneless reply, "Please go away." Now she pressed the contact that was Olivia Benson's. Despite Randall's faith, she didn't hold out much hope. It was a workday. Captain Benson probably wasn't answering her personal phone at this time of day. To her surprise, Benson picked up. . . . . . At the conclusion of the "Casual Days" fashion show, loud, lively "yacht rock" music was piped into the Olive Tree, with Buffett's "Margaritaville" foremost on the playlist. Alex had begun to check around for Bobbyas typical with him, he had bumped into a friend, this one from his old days in Narcotics, and the two men had wandered off into a corner to talkwhen Lydia de Ruysch popped up next to her. "I hope you had a good time!" "We've had a great time," Alex agreed with a smile over the thumping bass, "but now I need to collect the troops to get prepped for dinner. We're supposed to eat with my brother Jack and his wife tonight, and I wanted to bring a dessert. The kids are downstairs in the book department, and I have to round up Bobby." "I noticed Randall won the trendy boy's outfit," de Ruysch said happily. "He'll look wonderful in that shade of green." Alex picked up the shopping bag with the outfit. "Olivia teased him about a girl he likes in his class!" "Oh, ho, so adolescent hormones are raising their heads!" her friend joked and then turned to address a woman now standing behind her. "Speaking of Olivias, I wanted to introduce you to a friend of mine, if you haven't already met." Alex and Olivia Benson exchanged glances, then both burst out laughing. "I take it," de Ruysch commented dryly, "that you have." "Fourteen years ago to be precise," was Benson's answer. "Long time no see," she added jokingly, "like last Saturday." "Don't tell me you're actually taking an afternoon off!" Alex parried. "I wish." Benson shook her head, and de Ruysch gave a deep sigh. "We had a complaint of a sexual assault in one of the dressing rooms. Turns out it was a couple of teenagers making out in sportswear." "The whole crew is on other assignments, so I took the call," Benson confessed. "Margaritaville" segued into something softer and mellow, and it was then Alex noticed her phone vibrating. As she pulled it out, Benson's phone shrilled, and, with a surprised look, she fished her cell from her pocket and was puzzled as she glanced at the screen. "Connecticut?" She swiped to the right and crisply answered. "Olivia Two?" she returned a second later, and Alex, attempting to access her voicemail, looked up, startled. "Honey, slow down. Slowly, sweetheart..." "Liv?" Alex gasped. "All right. Keep watch. Don't move. We'll be right there. Stay calm!" "Liv!" "Find Bobby, I'm headed downstairs," and Benson wheeled and made a beeline for the elevator, Alex and de Ruysch at her heels. Bobby was already there, punching at the down button in frustration. "Min tried to call me. I don't know why the phone didn't ring. Christ..." His head swiveled. "Stairs. Come on." With the force of his shove, the metal stairwell door bounced against the concrete wall with a deafening bang, and he bolted down the staircase. Alex insisted, "Liv! What did she say?" Benson said tensely, "That Tito is downstairs, and that Randall is trying to save him." . . . . . Finally, Randall decided, he was getting through to Tito, his slow surrender having begun when Randall pleaded that Mrs. De Castro was still crying over his absence. He noticed the lower lip tremble, then the click of teeth as Tito curbed any reply. He remembered what his parents told them about abduction, that it changed you, twisted your mind into believing what your captors made you think was true. But Tito's reply had changed since he began his pleas. "This is where I belong now. You don't understand." "Carlos m-misses you," Randall persisted, now also keeping watch in the direction where Mrs. Van Amstel had last been seen. "The n-night I stayed over...oh, Tito, you r-remember; you and Carlos were talking g-guy stuff..." A tremor went through Tito, causing the sleeping Pomeranian to wiggle. "You teased me, 'cause I got r-red...but you said you and C-Carlos were bl-blood brothers...hermanos de sangreyou said!...he hasn't been the same since you left. He still cares. Please, Tito, D-Dad will protect you. And Mom, too. Th-They know what to do." "I am not the same either. I can't go back, it's too late for me. Go back to your sister, Randall. Go home," and now the voice was almost broken. Olivia jerked in terror as the door to Philip Socia's office opened, and Mrs. Van Amstel came striding out. The little drama between her assistant and Randall caught her attention instantly. "Manuel, what is the meaning of this?" "Manuel" immediately snapped to attention, rousing Flounce with a little growl, his face shuttering. Inwardly Randall cried out in frustration, and his already fast-beating heart gave a leap as the woman covered the distance from the office to where she had left her assistant in what seemed like the blink of an eye. He responded, in a frightened voice that did not have to be feigned, "Por favor, señora, estoy perdido. Ayúdeme," and was close enough to "Manuel" to hear him emit a tiny gasp. "Can the child not speak English?" Mrs. Van Amsteal asked impatiently. "Oh, but what can you expect these days from illegals? What did he say? Isn't perdido the word 'lost'?" "Perdido!" Randall repeated, biting his lower lip and pretending he hadn't understood. "Si, señora! Sin padre, sin madre!" And he clutched at "Manuel's" sleeve as if he were eight years old. "Manuel's" voice returned to its rote tones. "Yes, madam. The boy says he is lost and is looking for help. Since we will be heading home after your conference with Mr. Socia, we can leave him with Cole's security, or bring him to your niece. She will be sure to find his parents." Mrs. Van Amstel stepped forward until she was an arm's length from Randall, tilting her head inquisitively at him. "Such a handsome little lad. Such pretty eyes behind those glasses." She reached out and smoothed the top of Randall's hair. He almost recoiled. Was Olivia still watching? "He has such nice thick hair," and she smiled at her assistant, "the way yours was before you were so wicked over the weekend. But Lyddie and her security guards are busy today, what with the employee changeover this month. I don't think I'll bother her. We'll take him home with us, Manuel, feed him some lunch, and I'll have Miss Thornberg call the authorities. He can stay with us while we look for his parents. We'll make him feel at home." Randall knew the old Tito, the responsible Tito who had looked after his mother since his father deserted them, would have asked if it was a wise thing to doafter all, the parents of a lost child in a store surely were also in the store. Mrs. Van Amstel's mouth smiled, and other facial muscles followed, but her eyes did not. He remembered the look of the vagrant who had tried to steal his backpack when he'd hitchhiked to New York looking for his mother, those feral eyes, and something screamed at him to run, but he held his ground, and he felt "Manuel" tremble slightly. "Go ahead," she insisted, "tell him." "La señora te pide que..." [The lady asks that] And "Manuel's" voice failed. "Go on," Van Amstel urged, an edge to her words. Olivia opened her mouth to scream. Behind her and to the side, the elevator opened, and Olivia wheeled, then bolted from the safety of the books into Bobby's arms before he could take more than two strides forward, her breath coming in short gasps, her left hand pointing beyond the Book Arbor, her mouth open but no words coming out. "Let me," Benson ordered in low tones, her eyes on fire, and strode in the direction the child had pointed. She was too big to pick up, but Bobby did it nevertheless, carrying Olivia in a bear hug as they followed Benson. "Alex," de Ruysch whispered, "what is going on?" Alex's eyes were burning. "Please tell me you didn't know, Lydia. Please." "Excuse me? Mrs. Van Amstel?" Benson called out in a brisk, friendly voice as she emerged from the opposite end of the Book Arbor. "You're Marikje Van Amstel? I know you from the papers. You're a great supporter of our judicial system." Mrs. Van Amstel practically preened. "Why, yes, I am. And you are" "I'm Captain Olivia Benson, and I'm with the NYPD." At this point, Benson's voice was as smooth as proverbial honey. Bobby had lowered Olivia to the floor, and now the four of them, Lydia de Ruysch ashen but quiet, lined up behind the vine-wound trellis to observe. Mrs. Van Amstel had her chin tilted upward, looking reserved and affronted. Randall had dropped his hands to his sides. And "Manuel" was still standing stiffly, Flounce blinking in his arm, the shopping bags still dangling from his left hand, but he was perspiring now, and his breath had quickened. Benson continued in businesslike tones, "I'm here at Cole's assisting your niece with a security problem. Lydia noticed you and your assistant on the security camera, and I told her I needed to speak with you both." She smiled at "Manuel." "Hello. Lydia tells me you're Mrs. Van Amstel's assistant?" "Yes, he is," the older woman cut in. "Manuel Ramirez. He's been in my employ since May." Benson pretended not to notice how quickly she responded in "Manuel's" stead. "And this little fellow?" Mrs. Van Amstel smiled genially. "A lost child, who appealed to Manuel while I was meeting with Mr. Socia about the Christmas toy drive. We planned to take him to security to see if they could find his parents." Olivia wheeled to Bobby, outraged, and made the ASL sign for "No!" He nodded, cuing her with outstretched fingers to wait. Benson smiled at Randall, who responded with a weak one of his own. "Well, I'll certainly take that responsibility off your hands, Mrs. Van Amstel. It was kind of you to want to help the boy. I know you're a very busy woman." Alex's face was as close to the trellis vines as possible, her expression turned to ice. "However, it was Mr. Ramirez on that security camera who caught my attention, Mrs. Van Amstel. I need to ask: at the time you hired him, he had proper identificationa driver's license, for instancea resume, references? Is that correct?" "Of course," the imperious woman answered with a sniff. "I wouldn't have considered anyone without proper documentation. Manuel, put the bags down and show them your driver's license." "Manuel" hesitated, then lowered the bags to the floor, and started to reach into his pants' pocket. "No, no," Benson said sweetly. "I'm sure what you have appears to be in order. But I'm sorry to say, Mrs. Van Amstel, that his documents might be fake. You see, we have a missing persons report from Connecticut, a seventeen-year-old high school student who disappeared in February, a Sebastian De Castro. Your Mr. Ramirez appears to have shaved his head, and...had some body modifications done, but otherwise he matches the description we have from the Connecticut State Police," and here she moved to "Manuel's" left side, "down to this scar from a childhood fall, exactly the description of Mr. De Castro. "You'll understand, of course, as a longtime and law-abiding resident of this city, that I'm required to take Mr. Ramirez to the police station to corroborate his identity by taking fingerprints." She smiled. "We promise it won't take too long, Mrs. Van Amstel, and if it's mistaken identity, we're very sorry, but we do have to check it out." "This is all very irregular," Van Amstel frowned. "I'm thinking I should call my attorney." "I totally understand, and you should feel free to do so, Mrs. Van Amstel. You can meet us at the 16th precinct." She smiled at "Manuel." "If you'll come with me, Mr. Ramirez, this won't take long." Now he was frozen with fear. "I- I can't." Benson was firm, but kind. "You must." "Manuel" shook his head. "Madam will not permit" Benson asked in a low voice, "Why must you ask her permission, Manuel? You're of age, after all." "Isn’t that what your driver's license says?" Bobby padded forward with slow, even steps from the cover of the Book Arbor, his voice soft, coaxing. "That's correct, isn't it? And you work for her? She's your employer, correct?" If "Manuel" had thought Randall was an illusion, the appearance of his best friend's beloved "Mr. G" shook him to the core. He swallowed now, his eyes hunted, his body trembling. Still, he replied as if by rote, "Yes. That's what it says." "Of course he's Manuel Ramirez," Mrs. Van Amstel snapped impatiently, stepping forward. "Stop acting the fool, Manuel." Benson barred any further progress. "Let him answer." "Is that what you know? Or what you're expected to know? You're not acting the fool, are you?" Bobby stated gently, focused solely on "Manuel." "You're surviving. Like you have to, to avoid certain things." He glanced at Van Amstel. "Do you avoid her friends, too? Like Jonathan Belke who escorted Mrs. Van Amstel from Henri, the French restaurant, on Sunday night?" At the mention of Belke's name, there was an audible intake of breath from "Manuel." He began to tremble so hard that Flounce struggled in his arms, and a startled Randall caught the little dog before he fell. Bobby stepped next to "Manuel" and gently touched his shoulder. "Sebastian," he said quietly, as if talking to a small child. "Sebastian...Tito...she has no hold on you any longer. I promise. What happened last weekend?" Tears spilled from Tito's eyes. "It was that man. The white-haired man. He told me to call him 'Bear.' Madam...Mrs. Van Amstel wanted to buy some property from him. He told her he'd agree to her price if...if...if he could have...m-me for the weekend." Behind the screen, Lydia clapped a hand to her mouth and swayed in shock. Alex caught her, and she moaned almost inaudibly, "I swear to God, Alex, I didn't know..." "Manuel," and Mrs. Van Amstel demanded sternly, "you know perfectly well that we went to the country house to relax last weekend. You watched movies and swam in the pool while I conducted business with Mr. Belke. He's a noted and respected real estate developer, for heaven's sake. Why do you tell these filthy lies?" Olivia could bear it no longer and exploded from the Book Arbor with blazing eyes. "He's not lying, you are! Espèce de sorcière ! J'ai entendu chaque mot."[You witch! I heard every word!] She realized she had spoken in French, took a breath, and continued hotly, "Captain Benson, Tito was the one who said they should take Randall to security to find his lost parents. But she said no. She said Ms. de Ruysch and the security guards had too much work to do, and she was going to take him home with them. Feed him lunch. Make him feel at home." Randall, the boy who two years earlier could hardly look strangers in the eye, faced the elderly woman with determination. "That's what you said, Mrs. Van Amstel. Every s-single word." He turned to Benson. "You tell Mr. Ca-Carisi I'll sw-swear to it." "Sebastian," Benson assured him earnestly, "you're among friends now. Mr. and Mrs. Goren, and Olivia and Randall are here. You don't need to be afraid. Did Mrs. Van Amstel permit Mr. Belke to harm you?" Tito began to sob. "Yes. I still hurt now. He- He" His legs wobbled, then buckled, and Bobby caught him. "I've got you. I won't let you go." Voices came from the opposite side of the Book Arbor, then a tight-lipped Amanda Rollins strode in, with several uniformed officers behind her. She barked immediately, "Quicklyone of you, please find a chair for this young man." Benson's voice turned to iron. "Marikje Van Amstel, you are under arrest for participating in sexual exploitation of a minor" "Wait a moment!" Mrs. Van Amstel protested. "You can't arrest me!" Unmoved, Benson snapped a handcuff on the woman's left wrist. "willful abuse of a minor, and unlawful imprisonment of a person for sexual purposes. I'm sure there are more charges, but those seem a good enough starting point." Van Amstel tried to whip around, only to be caught by Rollins' strong arm, held in place while Benson snapped the cuff to her right wrist while continuing tonelessly, "You have the right to remain silent. Anything you say can and will be used against you in a court of law. You have the right to talk to an attorney for advice before we ask you any questions" "You have no right!" Benson tested the handcuffs with a tug of Van Amstel's wrist and continued doggedly, "You have the right to have an attorney with you during questioning. If you cannot afford an attorney, one will be appointed for you before any questioning if you wish. If you decide to answer questions now without an attorney present, you have the right to stop answering at any time. Do you understand these rights as they are stated to you?" "My attorney is Martin Steinbucher," Mrs. Van Amstel shot back. "I'll be eating dinner at home by the time this farce ends." "We'll see, Mrs. Van Amstel," Benson countered blandly. "Please accompany Detective Rollins." "I certainly shall not," declared Van Amstel. Lydia de Ruysch stepped from behind the vine-entwined trellis of the Book Arbor, with Alex next to her. Her lips were pursed and expression hard as her aunt insisted, "Lyddie! Look at what they're doing to me!" The silence lasted perhaps two seconds, but seemed longer. "Good," said de Ruysch finally in a flat voice. "They're taking you away. And if Mr. Steinbucher does manage to get you home in time for dinner, there will be at least one place you won't be welcome any longer. If you ever enter this store again, step one foot on the property, a guard will escort you out. If you resist, the police will be called." "Lydia!" gasped Van Amstel in shock. "You're taking my word over...some Spanish good-for-nothing telling lies about me?" "'Good-for-nothing'? Why? Because he has brown skin? Or because he won't give into your perversions? I've apologized for your lady-of-the-manor attitude for years, made excuses for your rude behavior. And now I find out you're not only rude" Her voice dropped to a whisper. "you're a monster! Captain Benson. Please. Escort. This. Woman. From. My. Store," de Ruysch finished, holding back angry tears, biting off each word. "The NYPD cannot do this to me!" Van Amstel flared. "You know who I am. I am a leader in this city." "I doubt if you'll be in city custody very long," Bobby spoke up grimly. "When you call your attorney, you might ask about Title 18, Part I, Chapter 117 of the United States Code, Section 2423: Transportation of Minors." "Title...Section...what nonsense is this?" Van Amstel retorted as Rollins attempted to turn her toward the elevator. Bobby, easing Tito into the oversized office chair that one of the uniforms had found and wincing when Tito flinched in pain, said coldly, "You obtained this young man by willingly supporting individuals involved in sex trafficking, some of whom are already being held on trafficking charges. "In full disclosure to you, Part A of Section 2423 states 'A person who knowingly transports an individual who has not attained the age of 18 years in interstate or foreign commerce, or in any commonwealth, territory or possession of the United States, with intent that the individual engage in prostitution, or in any sexual activity for which any person can be charged with a criminal offense, shall be fined under this title and imprisoned not less than 10 years or for life.' "Those persons already in custody and their accomplices in the trafficking charges may welcome giving up their customer list in exchange for leniency from Federal judges who don't take these activities lightly. State lines, Mrs. Van Amstel. You're no longer just New York's problem." Rollins marched her out of sight, still protesting. Benson was already on her phone again. "I need a bus at Cole's Department Store immediately. We have patient for transport in serious condition" "Liv!" de Ruysch interrupted. "Can you sent him to St. Vincent's? I know the director there." "Transport to St. Vincent's," Benson finished. "Tell them he's in pain from an assault, and almost certainly dehydrated, with possible blood loss. I'll be riding with him to the hospital." "Olivia" "Lydia, it's not your fault," Alex spoke up. "Maybe not, but it doesn't matterLiv, I want all his hospital bills sent to me. Alex, what about his family?" "There's just his mother," Alex added softly. Her daughter nestled next to her, and Alex embraced her with one arm. "I want to make sure his hospital room is large enough that his mother can stay with him if she wishes," de Ruysch insisted. "And if she prefers a hotel room, I'll have one reserved at the Aves one block down, with all meals provided." "We'll work on it," Benson promised, watching as Bobby squatted at Tito's side. The officer who had brought the chair had also brought water, and Bobby was letting him sip it slowly. Tito was flushed now, eyes half closed. "He'll probably be in ICU while the doctors determine the extent of his injuries...both physical and psychological." "I'll pay for that, too," de Ruysch said in angry tears. "The therapists, I mean. My God, how could she?" Flounce whined and struggled in Randall's arms, trying to get to Tito. "No, puppy, stop." Tito opened his eyes a little and, to their surprise, he tried to smile. "It's okay. He's my amigo... When I was homesick or hurting, he would find me and snuggle with me. I could hold him when I cried." "Right," Alex muttered bitterly as Randall gingerly laid Flounce in Tito's lap. The little dog stood on his hind legs, and, tail wagging, licked Tito's face. "The dog is more humane than the owner." "Then we'll take care of him until you're well again," Randall promised. "She won't be needing him for a while." Bobby patted Randall's arm with an encouraging smile, then turned back to Tito with the water bottle. "Have a little more," he urged, and kept administering water until the paramedics arrived. "All right," Benson sighed as Tito was readied for transport by gentle yet quick-moving paramedics. "I hate to make this afternoon even harder than it's been, but I'll need the four of you at headquarters for statements. I'll catch you back at the station after I finish at St. Vincent's. Officer Sanborn will escort you when you're ready." "We'll be there," Alex said firmly. She had her eyes on Bobby, who was rocking slightly forward and back, his eyes tracking the departure, trying to quench his anger. She understood that anger, having noticed how easily he had supported Tito, as easily as he'd carried Olivia moments earlier. Her mind flashed to a snowy January Saturday when Carlos had been working out with Bobby in their basement gym. Carlos had bragged that, at gym class, Tito had weighed in at 150 pounds. "He can bench-press nearly as much as you, Padrino." The boy just wheeled from Cole's looked thirty pounds lighter. Not just sexually abused, but starved. To keep him tame. Pliant. Subject to Van Amstel's will. She wanted to explode, too. Instead she touched Bobby's arm, grounding him, grounding herself. There was a sniffle behind her, then Olivia began to cry. Alex came back to earth with a jolt, and swiftly dropped into the chair that had been Tito's and gathered Olivia in her lap, unmindful of her size or her age. She was already as tall as Alex and almost the same weight, and seeing them together made Bobby realize once more how much time had passed. "Here's a chair, sir," Officer Sanborn said instinctively, rolling a second office chair toward Bobby. "Take a few minutes." Bobby sat down heavily and beckoned to Randall standing in front of him holding the Pomeranian, who had resigned himself to propping his head on Randall's shoulder. He had said nothing during the entire arrest and departures except for rebuking Flounce, just watched, as if in the midst of a dream. "Are you all right? Rand?" Randall swallowed, blinked. "I'm okay." Bobby was unconvinced, reaching forward to touch Randall's left hand. "Buddy? Are you able to tell us what happened? You don't have to if you don't want to." "It's okay, I c-can tell you." He paused. "'Livia and I were looking at the books..." He missed no detail. Between sniffles, Olivia soon began contributing her own observations. When he finished, Bobby laid a hand on Randall's left shoulder. "Randall...that is the bravest thing I've ever heard." Randall looked puzzled. "I wasn't being brave. I just wanted to get Tito away from her. He kept trying to send me away. And then she saw me, and I wanted to stall her until you and Mom showed up. That's why I pretended to only speak Spanish. The longer I talked to Tito, the more I was getting to him. I couldn't let her take him away again." "What if she'd taken you away?" Olivia demanded. "She wouldn't've," Randall insisted. "That's why I told you to watch me. I knew you'd come help." He halted, then added, "You said on Monday, Mom. 'You do what you have to do.'" Tears blurred Alex's eyes, and, for a moment, she couldn't speak. "Do you both think you can repeat that down at SVU?" "Yes, Mom." "Yes, Mama." Bobby looked up at the uniformed officer, a slightly stout Black man who wore a gentle smile at the family exchange. "I think we're ready, Officer Sanborn." . . . . . Benson walked into her squad room to find people eating lasagna. Alex asked instantly, "How is he?" Benson paused, looking down at Olivia and Randall, but the former returned her gaze with furrowed brows. "You don't have to fib, Captain Benson. We know what happened to him." Wearily, Benson sagged into an office chair, and Bobby cut her a square of lasagna and placed it on a paper plate along with a plastic fork and a napkin. "It's Mama Rosanot as good as Serafina's, but then what is? You must be hungry." "Yes," she replied, but poked at the lasagna, "and no." And because everyone's attention was on her, she added, "He's in bad shape, but the doctors say everything will heal with time. Physically, at least. Now that I'm here, I wanted to call Mrs. De Castro and arrange" "Eat. It's taken care of. Mrs. De Castro will be at St. Vincent's," and Bobby glanced at his watch, "any minute now. Shardand Abbi Diaz; Elena needs someone more fluent in English with herare driving her in, and Ana and Carlos staying at the Dark Crystal. I also know Mrs. Van Amstel will have the best attorney her money can buy. Well, so will Tito. Charles Saltonstall will be here on Saturday; I told him everything. He said the fees he gets from his wealthy clients let him take worthwhile cases pro bono." "He's licensed to practice in New York?" Benson asked, finally taking a forkful of lasagna. "Yes," Bobby affirmed. His own lasagna, she couldn't help noticing, was barely touched. A few minutes later, Noah called out from the hallway. "Mom? Mom, are you okay?" Benson turned as he pelted into the room. "Noah...is it that late already? Aren't you supposed to be at dance class?" "Mom, it's way after five o'clock. I've already been." Benson sighed. "It's later than I thought. Are you all right? I was going to take care of a few more details, then bring you home some of this...feast..." She cocked her head at Alex and Bobby. "Why do we have lasagna?" Alex confessed, "When we got here, I called Jack and told him I wasn't sure we'd make dinner tonight, explained what happened. Patty put away the dinner ingredients, and they brought lasagna from Mama Rosa's. They planned to bring extra for you and Amanda, and then decided it wasn’t fair to leave out Fin and the others." Noah wrapped his arms around his mother from behind, kissing her cheek, and explained, "I checked my phone after dance class. There was a big news report of police officers at Cole's, and they mentioned your name, and something about an ambulance. I had to make sure you were okay." Benson sighed again. "It was an abuse victim, Noah. I went with him to the hospital." She patted the table between her and Olivia. "Sit down, have something to eat." Olivia eyed him, and Noah asked, "May I sit next to you?" "That depends. Are you talking or scrolling?" Noah sighed. "I said I was sorry on Saturday night. Would it help if I bought you a frozen hot chocolate before you leave?" He knew she remembered the night at the bookstore; he had bought her the first frozen hot chocolate she'd ever tasted and fobbed off a very aggressive Faith Yancy with the help of Elliot Stabler. "Well...I s'pose. How big a slice do you want?" As she cut his slice, Noah turned his attention back to his mother. "I didn't mean to forget. Is the person all right, Mom?" Randall put down his fork. "It's Tito, Noah. And...he's hurt...really bad. 'Livia and I found him, at Cole's." "Tito? You mean Carlos's friendthe one who was kidnapped? He's been here, in the city, all along?" Noah looked back and forth from Randall to his mother and back again. "Since May at least," Benson admitted. "And it wasn't some creepy pervert guy who had him," Olivia mourned, setting down the knife. "It was a rich lady, a rich lady who could have anything she wanted in the world and she hurt him instead." Her eyes burned. "I wish I could hurt her the way she hurt Tito." "No, you don't," Bobby reminded gently, reaching across the table to put his hand over hers. "You're not anything like her, Min. You're kind and fair and good." Olivia gulped and sniffled, and instead of eating, Noah put his arm around her. "It's okay. My mom will take care of it." "And the FBI," Randall finished grimly. "I hope they put her in a hole. With cockroaches." Benson gently updated them on Tito's care, and they put a small dent in the lasagna. Fifteen minutes later she had to take a call; after a few words, she looked surprised, then said, "All right, send them up." Minutes later, Richard Carver appeared on the opposite side of the glass doorways, his face grave under his purple-and-silver-streaked dark hair. Immediately, a tall young whirlwind pushed past him, shoving the glass doors open fiercely. "Padrino, I gotta see him. Shard wouldn't let me go in..." Bobby sighed and stood up, his makeshift napkin falling to the floor. "Carlos! You were supposed to stay with Ana." "She's safe with TJ and Sharon," Carlos Serrano protested. In the bright fluorescent lights of the SVU squad room, everyone could tell he'd been weeping, the dried tears visible on his cheeks. "Mr. G...Padrino! Please!" "Sit, Carlos," Alex bade, pulling up a chair for him. Carlos choked on his tears. "Madrina, I can't." Benson rose, crossing to his side. "Carlos. You can't. Not tonight. Only his mother can be with him, and your abuela to translate for her. He's on IVs and pain meds right now, and probably can't speak anyway. Tomorrow. Okay? I'll speak with his doctors." She put her arm around his shoulders and walked him away, quietly telling him of Tito's injuries. Shard motioned to Bobby and Alex, and, taking them aside, commented regretfully, "I don't know how Tito's going to take it. He refused to see Elena at first. He said...he said he wasn't fit for her to see, that he was a sinner. She had to put her foot down. But your Ms. de Ruysch did her due diligence. There's a hospital bed in the room for Elena, and when I left they were arranging for a cot for Abbi." He glanced at Carlos. "I figured since I was here, I'd see Mom and Dad for a couple hours. You want me to come back and we can hog-tie him in my car and I'll take him back to Milbury?" "He bring clothes?" Bobby asked. Shard held up a backpack. "A spare shirt, two pairs of shorts, and a change of socks." Alex decided briskly, "He can stay with us. He'll have to sleep on the sofa, though. You go on home. Say hi to your mother and father for us." "We owe you one," Bobby added. "Money for gas would be a help. You obviously didn't see the prices at the pump today," Shard joked, but Bobby promptly dug into his pocket and gave him a fifty. "Hey, I didn't drive by way of Albany!" "Consider it a carrying charge," Bobby countered, and Shard nodded, then walked past Carlos and patted him on the shoulder. "It's all right, Carlito. It'll be all right. Patience." Carlos nodded. . . . . . Tito didn't want to see him, but Bobby Goren and Olivia Benson had prepared him carefully. Carlos waited in the doorway. What he wanted most to do was weep, or rage against the injustice of a battered and traumatized friend lying pale in a hospital bed, his face weary with pain, and, worst of all, shame. "I can't," Tito had moaned weakly. "Mamá, I can't. I can't let anyone...see me. I'm not...right anymore." Mrs. De Castro, or his abuela, had dimmed the lights, but the low beeping of medical equipment persisted. Carlos restrained his negative feelings in favor of better ones. "Nothing's different," Carlos stated in a low voice, pitched just loud enough for only Tito to hear. "I still see my friend, my best friend, my hermano de sangre. Your soul is still the same, mi hermano, and God knows it. I'll be sitting here, in the door, to be with you until Mr. G comes to pick me up tonight. And tomorrow, too, and Sunday morning before we leave. I won't desert you."
And he'd taken his place in the doorway, removing his backpack and sitting in a grey plastic bucket chair out of the way of the hospital staff, and waited. Abi-Abi and Tito's mother had finally gone to breakfast, while Carlos pulled a paperback book from his backpack and began to read. After a few minutes, he spoke as if to no one in particular. "This is for history class. I thought it would be boring, but it's not. It's nonfiction, about human society. Guns, Germs and Steel." Five minutes later, Tito rasped, "You should be in school." "Mr. G and I talked to the principal this morning," Carlos said quietly. "We told him it was a family emergency and that I could make the work up on Labor Day. You know I can. Mr. Stocker agreed." "He didn't answer," Carlos continued, as he dug into the last of the lasagna at the kitchen table of the Hogan apartment on Thursday night, "but then, right before Abi-Abi and Ms. Elena came back, he asked me if Randall was okay. And...then...we just talked. Not about what happened. He started talking about when we were kids. Stuff we got into." "Right now, he's safe talking about the past. It's a refuge for him," Bobby explained. "When he feels more comfortable, hopefully he'll take the next step back into the world." Carlos continued, "Abi-Abi and Ms. Elena saw us talking, and they went into the waiting room and let us talk alone for a long time." He glanced at Bobby. "I waited so long for this day. But now we have to wait again, don't we?" Bobby just nodded, and Alex sighed, and Carlos continued thoughtfully, "That Ms. de Ruysch, she's somethin', though. She came in three times. She got us lunch. She asked Tito if there was anything he needed every single time. She told us there's an attorney coming to see him on Saturday. Is she paying for that, too?" Bobby explained, "It's Charles Saltonstall. We want to make sure Mrs. Van Amstel's attorney doesn't get the upper hand. It's the kind of pro bono work he loves. And speaking of Mrs. Van Amstel, the Manhattan EDA was able to get a search warrant issued for her townhouse. Liv hopes there's more evidence. Baxter was furious. His family has been friends with the Van Amstels for decades. They're still waiting for a warrant from Greene County for the country house. And her new attorney advised her that if she wanted to be considered cooperative, she should give up the location of Jonathan Belke. SVU's been chasing him for years. He's molested teen boys before. He took a chance on coming into the city on Sunday and lost." "Ms. de Ruysch's been really nice. She keeps apologizing for what 'Tante Marika' did." Carlos smiled. "Ms. Elena keeps telling her it wasn't her fault. She even said that if Tito wants to see Flounce, she'll get permission for him. He seems to like you, Rand. Would you like to take Flounce to see Tito, or do you think he'll let me take him?" Randall didn't answer; he was staring at the little Pomeranian, whom Sam the collie had immediately taken in hand. Flounce was used to being alpha dog, but Sam had set a big paw gently yet firmly down on the fluffy dog barking and nipping at him Thursday night, waiting him out until the Pom stopped yapping and wagged his tail. Sam, in turn, licked his face and led him to the dog treats, and now Flounce was curled up inside the curve of Sam's belly as the collie stationed himself at Randall's side. The children had been animated at the 16th precinct, but, since their return to the apartment the previous night, had gone quiet. Bobby and Alex let them choose how much they wanted to do, or whether they wanted to do anything at all. When Olivia woke up screaming that Thursday night, Alex took her into bed with her, and Bobby bunked in with Randall. "Dad," Randall had begun as his father started to slip under the covers; instead Bobby sat at the edge of the bed and said, "Yes, buddy?" He looked so small again, almost the youngster they'd brought home. When he'd given his statement to Fin Tutuola, he'd stood stiff and tall like a miniature soldier, carefully reciting the facts. He'd forgotten nothing, even Mrs. Van Amstel's words comparing his hair to Tito's. Bobby's anger had boiled to the surface again, knowing why Tito's head had been shaven. "I didn't mean to scare everyone," Randall confessed to him, chewing his lower lip. "I was afraid if 'Livia and I came upstairs to get you, Mrs. Van Amstel would leave with Tito. I wouldn't have left 'Livia alone with her, and 'Livia wouldn't have left meand then who would have believed us anywayexcept you and Mom and Captain Benson? Then she could have denied everything, and she just could have kept him at home from now on and nobody could help him." Bobby opened his arms and Randall gratefully sank into them. It was oftener that Alex hugged him; they had bonded first and had never fallen out of the habit. She had held him so tightly at the squad room afterward that he'd protested. At that moment, Bobby was profoundly grateful to have Randall in his arms, safe and sound, even though sorrowful. "Right now, I can't think of anything else," he finally said quietly, releasing Randall from the hug, "but I do know…that right nowand every day for the past two yearsI'm very glad…that when Captain Benson found out about you, that we were the people she contacted first." He smiled a little, remembering the Mets game. "I wouldn't trade you for a dozen boys who play baseball." On Friday, while Carlos had been at the hospital, they had gone to Central Park rather than one of the museums they had planned, picking up a deli picnic lunch on the way. They'd taken it slowly: walked the Ramble; seen all the locations filmed for movies and television; visited the Balto, Mother Goose, and Alice in Wonderland statues; stopped at the Alexander Hamilton monument, and finally picnicked at Sheep Meadow under the trees, discussing the first day of school, Thanksgiving, the upcoming visit of Olivia's half-brother Laurent, wife Noémie, and little Francie. On the return route, Bobby and Alex deliberately led them past Frances Hodgson Burnett's memorial fountain. "It's Mary and Dickon, isn't it, from The Secret Garden," and Olivia had finally brightened, taking a photo which she later saved as wallpaper for her laptop. "If Colin could come out of darkness" Here she stared at Bobby with big eyes. "there's a chance for Tito, isn’t there?" "Resurgens," reminded Bobby with a hug. They left by way of the path leading to the Plaza Hotel, and Bobby pointed to a bench. "There's where I met Sébastien Anouilhin my fedora." He was rewarded with Olivia's snort, and even a smile from Randall, who knew the story of Madame Pepin's downfall. "May we visit Eloise, Papa?" And so they had made their way into the famous hotel to see the portrait of its most well-known fictional guest, then finally returned home. Later, when Bobby went to the hospital to walk Carlos back to the apartment, he found the latter stuffing a three-pack of briefs, another of socks, and a change of t-shirt with a Knicks logo on it into his backpack. "Mike Logan brought it by," Carlos confessed, abashed. "Told me next time I need to think when I pack." Bobby had gone into the room to greet Abbi Diaz and ask after Elena De Castro's health, and finally he approached Tito's bed. "Hey, man. When you're betterwhen you're...um...up to it, we'll be there." Tito couldn't yet meet his gaze, but he whispered, "Thanks, Mr. G." . . . . . It was Saturday night, the final day of their vacation. During the evening, they'd worked out the logistics of getting six people, a big dog, and a birdcage, it being a collapsible one notwithstanding, home in a Honda Pilot, finally deciding on Bobby driving and Carlos up front; Abbi, Randall, and Alex in the center seat; and Olivia in the back with Sam. Randall said he would hold Flounce. It would be a tight fit, but only for ninety minutes, and Bobby hoped there would be no delays on the interstate. They would leave their souvenirs and books at the Hogan apartment and pick them up on another visit. When they'd asked the children if the latter was okay, Randall had nodded at the solution. "It's okay. It's just books." The only thing Randall insisted on bringing home would be pinned to his shirt: the souvenir detective's badge Benson had given him, with her badge number. He had even worn it to bed every night. Olivia asked if they could go home by the Tappan Zee; at this point, Bobby and Alex would refuse the children nothing within reason. Eleven days of fun and a successful resolution to six months of waiting and hope had still come wrapped in trauma. "Maybe..." Olivia had requested as an afterthought, "we could skip lasagna for awhile?" and Randall had nodded. The feeling was unanimous. Lydia de Ruysch remained the designated Guardian Angel for the rest of the week. She hired two full-time assistants, both fluent in Spanish, so there would always be someone to help Mrs. De Castro when Abbi Diaz returned home. Once Tito left the hospital, the assistants would be replaced by full-time nurses, with the same arrangement. Jonathan Belke had been taken into custody; the FBI agent who arrived to coordinate with the NYPD turned out to be Fredo Salvani, who'd worked with Bobby long ago on the Valdez case. Belke was denied bail. Mrs. Van Amstel, as expected, had managed bail, but at a price: Martin Steinbucher had dropped her like a proverbial hot potato. She'd arrived in court with a showy substitute, Donnell Prince, who favored cases that brought him attention. Charles Saltonstall, looking like a modern-day William Hopper clad in Armani, and, with his Boston vibes intact, was there to observe, taking notes by hand. Prince did not look happy. When Marikje Van Amstel left the courtroom following her bail hearing, she passed by a gauntlet of impassive faces: Olivia Benson, Amanda Rollins, Terry Bruno, Jake Griffin, Renee Curry, Fin Tutuola. Along with the SVU CSU, each had been, in turn, at her townhouse in performance of the search warrant, missing nothing. Standing by the doors was Dominick Carisi. Next to him were Elliott Stabler and Anyana Bell. "Solidarity in numbers," Stabler told Benson as the doors closed. That evening, Olivia and Randall had listened to the latest installment of A Tree Grows in Brooklyn. Bobby sat with them until they had fallen asleep. Now he and Alex were showered and ready to climb under the covers until Bobby's phone chimed. "Zoom call request," he noted briefly, and brought his laptop into the bed and booted it up. "Harry?" Alex wondered. As the screen blossomed on Bobby's laptop, it was indeed Harry Cavanaugh, his fleshy face a bit sunburnt, his hair gone completely white since they'd seen him last. He looked tired, but brightened when he saw the two of them on the screen. "Alex," and he bobbed his head. "This guy treating you right?" "As always," said Alex soberly. "But it's been a hard three days." "Thought y'all were on vacation," Cavanaugh frowned. "Kids okay?" "For now, and we're heading home tomorrow," Bobby answered. "I'll explain...um...another time...it's late. What's the score?" Cavanaugh countered unexpectedly, "I want to hear your theory first." Bobby sighed. "Damn, Harry..." He paused, then used the fingers of his left hand to count off. "Micah caught his brother in flagrante delicto. He'd heard stories about other assaults. He took epic revenge, and his lodge buddies the sheriff and the medical examiner helped him cover it up when they heard the story. Then Micah took his own life and the same two covered that up, so he, devout Christian at heart, could be buried in sacred ground, and COVID got the blame." Cavanaugh rolled his eyes in a way Olivia would have understood. "Jesus, Goren, why'd you even ask me to look into it?" "To establish the facts. To make sure my feelings didn't get in the way of the truth." Cavanaugh dropped his usual bantering tone. "Well, Sergeant Friday, the facts are...Micah worked for the local co-op till the day he died. Used to go to Chicago every coupla months for business meetings. Told his lodge buddies he was startin' to notice little things moved around in the house when he was away, minor stuff, a salt cellar out of place, his alarm clock tilted the wrong way. His final trip to Chicago was just at the COVID lockdown. He anticipated it and came home a day early. Found his brother naked with a fifteen-year-old" "Bastard!" Alex hissed. "tied to the four-posters of his own bed. The county medical examiner's daughter. That gentleman told me" "How much liquor did you feed him?" Bobby said in disbelief. "Less than you think, because it works best with the good stuff. Smoother, so they don't notice how much they've consumed. A 90-buck bottle of Blanton's did the trick. In any case, Derwent told me Micah didn't even remember marchin' to the gun case, unlockin' it, gettin' the shells, or loadin' the shotgun. Did say it was pretty bloody in there. "Micah had already freed the girl and wrapped her in his robe, carried her to the living room after he tied up his little brother. Next thing she heard was a big boom. Twelve-gauge'll do that. He called his buds and soothed the poor child until they showed up. They cleaned it all up. The second time didn’t take as long because Micah used a .38. Mr. Retired Medical Examiner bragged to me that you could spray the whole room with Luminol and you wouldn't find a smidge." "So Shaw was right about everything," sighed Bobby bitterly. "Yeah...about that. That attorney of yours...Fessiden? I have a number for him to call: Aaron Tucker, Esq. in York. I think Troyer finally figured out what happened to Rosalind and realized he wronged her, but he lost contact with the family after his wife died. Or maybe he was just too fucking ashamed to call after the way he treated her. Troyer has a will. There's some money coming to Randall as Rosalind's heir. Should get him through all or most of college if invested properly by that Julian Volpe dude you know." "The daughter?" Bobby asked before Alex could. "She's...doing okay. They sent her away for a while, together with her mom, to her aunt's place. She was checked out, received...treatmentshe still goes. She's at UPenn now, studying chemistry." Cavanaugh cocked his head. "Has justice been served?" Bobby looked troubled. "Justice without mercy..." he began, and Alex recalled those words from long ago. Cavanaugh was always forthright. "Malachi Troyer is dead and can't ruin any more lives. His killer is dead. Micah Troyer is dead by his own hand, together with his own guilt. Dick Wilson, the sheriff, died in a car crash two years ago. Peter Derwent, the medical examiner, has bone cancer. He told me he may have six months left, that it felt good to get 'all that shit' off his chest. Rosalind Troyer Shaw is gone, and Sterling Shaw is where he always belonged. Let Randall grow up in peace." "Yes," Bobby agreed in relief. "Harry...come by sometimeOlivia always likes seeing you. Thanks." "You're welcome...Bob." And the screen went blank. Bobby closed the laptop, returning it to its case for the next day's departure, stacking it on the suitcase. Then he stepped back to the bed and slipped under the covers, and Alex followed suit, watching him, wondering. "Eames," he said with a sigh, "I want to be bored." She eyed him sideways. "You?" He reconsidered. "Maybe that was the wrong word. Routine. I want routine, at least for awhile. I want to make our kids breakfast in the morning and pick them up from school at night. Help them with their homework. Go to Olivia's tennis matches and Big Brothers/Big Sisters. Rake leaves with Carlos and watch Ana go on her first date now that she's had her quinceañera. Walk our dog and re-trim my beard after our stylist parakeet gets done nibbling on it. Work on whatever book is on my mind that morning. Get my trivia questions in a row and enjoy our Saturdays and Tuesdays." And he smiled at her. "And spend every day with you." She rested her head against his shoulder. "Let's make it happen then." After the lights were out, he reached out for her, and she for him. "Good-night, Agent Goren." "Good-night, Captain Eames."
|